The Comicologist » Marvel

Deadpool vs Jar Jar Binks

The Comicologist — Thu, 04 Mar 2010 02:40:49 +0000

If you haven't embraced Deadpool yet (metaphorically of course), here's one more reason to. A nice little titbit from "Deadpool: Merc With a Mouth" #5.

Clearly no love for Jar Jar. If only Deadpool had had a chance to sit down with George Lucas prior to Phantom Menace things might have turned out differently.

Deadpool: Merc With A Mouth #3,4,5 hard-to-find issues,a must-have set of comics

0 Bid

US $2.99

1h 15m

Deadpool 69 Last Issue Agent X X-Men Uncanny X-Force Wolverine Merc With A Mouth

1 Bid

US $9.99

2h 30m

Deadpool 68 Agent X X-Men Uncanny X-Force Wolverine Merc With A Mouth Lot Run

1 Bid

US $9.99

2h 30m

Deadpool 37 Agent X X-Men Uncanny X-Force Wolverine Merc With A Mouth Thor Loki

0 Bid

US $9.99

2h 30m

DEADPOOL MERC WITH A MOUTH #3 MARVEL ZOMBIES HEAD TRIP

US $2.49

2h 45m

Secret Invasion

The Comicologist — Mon, 06 Jul 2009 05:20:33 +0000

Having just finished reading the latest Marvel super "event" Secret Invasion, I have to say, I hope they decide to wait a while before they launch in to the next major cross over event. In my opinion "Secret Invasion" collecting issues #1-8 of the Secret Invasion mini-series, felt forced and more than a little dull.

In case you haven't read a Marvel comic published in the last two year, Secret Invasion provides a conclusion of sorts the the slow building Skrull plot for world domination. The Skrull are an alien race of shape shifters, who, after conducting tests on a couple of high profile heroes, including Mr Fantastic, develop the perfect plan to infiltrate human kind and break down various superhero teams from the inside. Basically the Skrull kidnapped a series of super heroes and replaced them with Skrull's. Cunning.

When the New Avengers kill Elektra, only to find her turn out to be a Skrull, the plot is revealed and distrust within the super hero community builds. Will the fractured super community be able to band together, and trust one another, long enough to end the threat and repel the Skrull invasion? No points for guessing the answer to that one.

The whole Secret Invasion arc also seems to serve as a get out of jail free card for Marvel, allowing them to bring back character previously assumed as being dead, using the "they weren't really dead, they were just abducted by Skrulls" device.

Perhaps the most interesting element of Secret Invasion for me was the conclusion, with Norman Osbourne poised to play a more prominent, and interesting role in the Marvel universe.

The major problem with this series is the pacing of the plot. Flicking through the first few issues it feels very slow, as if not much is happening, then the pace picks up at the end, to the point where it's as if Bendis was trying to cram a lot in.

Secret Invasion was also clearly written to contain just enough detail to remain coherent, whilst leaving plenty of plot gaps ready to be filled by countless crossover tie-ins. Basically every Marvel title seems to have had at least one of its own Secret Invasion tie-ins. Secret Invasion is a perfect example of when good story telling gets taken over by comic commercialism. With all that said, this series did not grab me enough to encourage me to pick up any of the tie-ins.

Overall I'd give this mini-series a 3 out of 10.

SIGNED GREG HORN MS MARVEL #30 SECRET INVASION SKRULLS

US $3.99

26m

MARVEL The Mighty Avengers v 3 SECRET INVASION 1 12-15

US $5.99

52m

Captain Marvel Ms. Marvel Secret Invasion VF 2008

US $3.85

1h 2m

Secret Invasion Chronicles 1 Marvel VF 2009

US $3.45

1h 4m

Secret Invasion Chronicles 2 Marvel VF 2009

US $5.20

1h 5m

Marvel Comics Secret Invasion Set 2008

US $85.00

1h 12m

complete set (8) 1st print run SECRET INVASION #1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 BENDIS MARVEL NM

US $9.99

Heroclix Marvel Secret Invasion #002 Moloid

US $1.27

2h 11m

Marvel Secret Invasion Who Do You Trust Trade Paperback

US $16.00

2h 14m

MARVEL HEROCLIX SECRET INVASION COMMON ENERGIZER

US $1.00

2h 15m

MARVEL HEROCLIX SECRET INVASION COMMON TOMBSTONE

US $1.00

2h 16m

Heroclix Marvel Secret Invasion #021 Iron Man

US $2.08

2h 28m

Heroclix Marvel Secret Invasion #032b Dum Dum Dugan

US $1.57

2h 28m

Heroclix Marvel Secret Invasion #042a Captain Mar-Vell

US $7.71

2h 46m

Heroclix Marvel Secret Invasion #043 Psycho-Man Rare

US $1.47

2h 46m

Captain Marvel Secret Invasion Marvel HC 50% Off!

US $9.99

3h 26m

Captain Marvel Ms Marvel Secret Invasion Infiltration #0 VF

US $7.20

3h 46m

Captain Marvel Secret Invasion HC (2008) #1-1ST NM

US $9.00

3h 51m

Marvel Heroclix Secret Invasion 060 Super Skrull Avengers Super Rare

US $19.95

4h 25m

MS. MARVEL #26. SECRET INVASION

1 Bid

US $1.06

4h 40m

Deadpool movie finally gets the nod

The Comicologist — Thu, 07 May 2009 01:56:00 +0000

The Marvel website has confirmed that the Merc with a Mouth, Deadpool, will be getting his very own solo movie. This is big news... for me at least... There is not a lot of information available as yet but Marvel are saying that... well not a lot, so I'll just cut and paste:

The newly confirmed Deadpool film, which would be produced by Lauren Shuler Donner and Marvel, has Ryan Reynolds slated to star and would be a complete exploration of the character - his origins, his emergence as the Merc with the Mouth, and more!

This news is enough to give me a cyber chubby. I am hoping that they completely forget about the "Deadpool" that featured in the closing stages of the Wolverine movie though. For me that was the worst part of the Wolverine film.

Super Hero Squad Taskmaster Deadpool figures Marvel

3 Bids

US $13.00

15m

CABLE AND DEADPOOL #3 MARVEL 2004 NM 9.4

US $4.00

49m

DEADPOOL CORPS #8 MARVEL COMICS

US $2.39

1h 23m

Uncanny X-Men: Divided We Stand

The Comicologist — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 02:33:37 +0000

Following the epic X-Men event Messiah Complex, all the major X-Men title underwent a reshuffle. To be honest, it's easy to get confused with what is currently going on in the X-Universe. Following Messiah Complex (MC), the X-Men are divided, hence the whole confusing "Divided We Stand" tag line, which is used across a couple of the titles. Uncanny X-Men "Divided We Stand" collects issues #495-499 of the Uncanny X-Men, and was written by Ed Brubaker.

The Uncanny X-Men seems to drop the pre-MC team of X-Men in favor of picking up with Cyclops and Emma Frost as they ponder the death/disappearance of Professor X while holidaying in the Savage Land. Cyclops is particularly broody as he contemplates whether or not to bring the X-Men back together. The two are eventually drawn to San Francisco when things there get weird. San Francisco has gone back to an idolized 1960's version of itself, and the X-Men that are there, Angel, Warpath and a few others, are all brainwashed into thinking they are flower children.

Meanwhile Wolverine, Nightcrawler and Colossus are on a holiday of their own in Russia, and for no apparent reason stumble upon the Russian version of the Weapon X program, curious as to why the X-Men retain their powers while all their mutants have been rendered powerless, following M-Day.

Long story short, both stories resolve themselves with little major impact upon any of the characters. There are two things that this book does that will set the direction for future Uncanny X-Men stories. Firstly, San Francisco is the new X-Men base of operations. Secondly, there appears to be a new "Sisterhood of Mutants" getting together.

Given that this collection was written by Ed Brubaker I have to say I was a little disappointed. I'd expected more. Sadly, this book is quite forgettable, ask me what happened in it a few months from now, and I will probably have forgotten. It's not the worst book I've read, but by the same token, it's all fairly stock standard X-Men fare. I'll pick up the next collection, but if it's on a par with this, then I think it might be time for me to give the Uncanny X-Men a break for a while.

Overall, I'd give this book 5 out of 10.

The Uncanny X-Men #499 Divided We Stand DWS

US $2.25

6h 36m

UNCANNY X-MEN Divided We Stand Graphic Novel - Ed Brubaker, Michael Choi

US $12.95

3d 11h 40m

X-MEN DIVIDED WE STAND #1 (of 2) NM Carey Peterson Uncanny Movie

US $1.89

4d 19m

Uncanny X-Men #498 Divided We Stand Tie-In

US $1.00

4d 7h 32m

X-MEN: DIVIDED WE STAND #1 & 2 VF/NM FULL SET UNCANNY

US $3.49

5d 58m

UNCANNY X-MEN #497 Divided We Stand 2008 Marvel Comics

US $2.99

5d 16h 13m

UNCANNY X-MEN #497 Skrull Variant Divided We Stand 2008

US $7.99

5d 16h 17m

Uncanny X-Men #496 Divided We Stand

US $.99

6d 23h 13m

Uncanny X-Men #498 - Divided We Stand (NM)

US $11.04

7d 21h 29m

Uncanny X-Men #497! 1 in 50 Variant Divided We Stand

US $30.00

11d 22h 39m

UNCANNY X-MEN #498 Divided We Stand 2008 Marvel Comics

US $2.99

12d 23h 21m

UNCANNY X-MEN #499 Divided We Stand 2008 Marvel Comics

US $2.99

12d 23h 23m

UNCANNY X-MEN #495 Divided We Stand 2008 Marvel Comics

US $3.99

14d 3h 54m

Marvel Uncanny X-Men Divided We Stand Promo Card

US $5.00

16d 21h 42m

UNCANNY X-MEN #496 Divided We Stand 2008 Marvel Comics

US $2.99

22d 17h 8m

Uncanny X-Men #496 Divided We Stand: Part 2!

US $2.24

24d 12h 43m

MARVEL COMICS UNCANNY X-MEN #495 DIVIDED WE STAND PART 1 BRUBAKER CHOI OBACK

US $5.00

25d 16h 51m

Uncanny X-Men: Divided We Stand Softcover

US $11.99

27d 19h 54m

Uncanny X-Men: Divided We Stand TP/Brubaker/Choi/Oback/Marvel Comics

US $14.95

29d 22h 30m

White Tiger: A Hero’s Compulsion

The Comicologist — Thu, 29 Jan 2009 05:31:03 +0000

White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion was written by Tamora Pierce and Timothy Liebe, and began it's 6 issue mini-series in 2006, but has since been released in trade paper back form, White Tiger #1-6.

The White Tiger mini-series follows the emergence of the White Tiger, Angela Del Toro. Fans of the Daredevil series would know that Del Toro first appeared in a number of issues of Daredevil, as an FBI agent drawn into the investigation of the Daredevil's true identity, as well as the investigation into the death of her uncle Hector, the previous White Tiger. In Daredevil, Del Toro quit the FBI when she realised the good she could do with her new found power, inherited via her uncle's Jade Tiger amulets, eventually taking on the White Tiger moniker.

White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion begins with Daredevil Matt Murdock in prison, leaving Del Toro seemingly on her own to figure out what to do with her new found power and responsibility. Del Toro, with the help of Black Widow, Luke Cage, Spider-Man and Iron Fist (who is doubling as Daredevil while Matt Murdock is in prison), eases herself into the role of White Tiger. While starting to clean up her neighbourhood, Del Toro finds herself investigating the shady activities of an organisation called Chaneyi.

In many respects White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion is a standard superhero tale. An FBI agent, inherits powers that improve her ability to fight crime. In that regard, there is nothing revolutionary or ground breaking going on, yet still, it's an enjoyable enough story. The story concluded as most comic arcs do, leaving the door wide open for a followup. It's a bit of a shame that Marvel didn't decide to take White Tiger further, but I guess they too didn't see enough to set the title apart from a host of other comics hitting the stands at the time.

Don't hold your breath for any Del Toro/White Tiger follow up either, as, from what I've read, White Tiger is killed by Lady Bullseye in a relatively recent issue of Daredevil.

Overall, I'd give White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion 6 out of 10

Hand Ninja & White Tiger Marvel Minimates 2-PACK Series 38 Sealed 2-Pack

US $8.95

32m

White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion TPB Marvel

US $3.99

1d 20h 15m

Peter Parker The Spectacular Spiderman 10 Marvel 1977 White Tiger

US $.99

2d 6h 38m

WHITE TIGER: A HEROES COMPULSION, Marvel 2007 - Tamora Pierce, Phil Briones

US $14.96

2d 13h 6m

WHITE TIGER issue 1 MARVEL COMICS

0 Bid

US $1.56

3d 15h 26m

White Tiger (2007) (Marvel) #1-6 (NM/MT) Complete

US $30.00

3d 16h 17m

White Tiger Heros Compulsion Marvel Comics TPB Trade Paperback Daredevil Knights

US $5.00

3d 23h 40m

The Incredible Hulk Marvel Heroclix- 020 White Tiger -Lee

US $1.00

4d 2h 32m

Marvel Minimates White Tiger Loose Shadowland

0 Bid

US $.99

4d 5h 58m

Marvel Heroclix Incredible Hulk 020 White Tiger

US $2.00

4d 6h 36m

White Tiger #1-6 Set/Timothy Liebe/Phil Briones/2007 Marvel Comics

US $9.95

4d 22h 5m

White Tiger #1-6 Near Complete Set (Marvel 2007) bagged/boarded VF/NM

1 Bid

US $3.00

4d 23h 13m

Marvel Heroclix 1x White Tiger #020 Incredible Hulk

US $1.49

5d 20h 51m

White Tiger Marvel Comics Lot 1-4 Run First Prints Nm-m Condition

0 Bid

US $1.99

6d 12m

Marvel the Stalking White Tiger Figurine

US $14.95

6d 25m

Heroclix Marvel The Incredible Hulk (Uncom) White Tiger W/Card

US $1.95

6d 1h 53m

THE HUMAN FLY #9 VF MARVEL WHITE TIGER APPEARANCE 1978

US $5.10

6d 6h 2m

White Tiger: A Hero's Compulsion by Tamora Pierce (2007, Paperback) Marvel

US $9.99

6d 16h 7m

2010 MARVEL H & V SKETCH CARD 1/1 White Tiger/Lady Bullseye by Hughes

US $65.00

6d 19h 20m

WHITE TIGER - WOMEN OF MARVEL TRADING CARDS

US $1.00

6d 20h 1m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 4: The Draco

The Comicologist — Tue, 13 Jan 2009 01:10:03 +0000

Uncanny X-Men Volume 4: The Draco collects issues #428-434 of Uncanny X-Men, and was written by Chuck Austen. The stuff I've read of Austen so far, Uncanny X-Men Volumes 1-3, have been terrible to say the least.

Picking up Volume 4, The Draco, I have to say I was pleasantly surprised when I read the prologue.

The prologue to The Draco, provides some interesting back story as to the true origins of Nightcrawler (Kurt Wagner), the circumstances surrounding his birth, and how he came to arrive in the care of sorceress and gypsy queen Margali Szardos. Mystique is Kurt's mother, and as it turns out Azazel is Kurt's father.

At the conclusion of the prologue however, the storyline goes down hill fast. Kurt is drawn to an archaeological dig. It turns out that a lot of teleporting mutants are being drawn to the same place, and that's not the only thing they have in common. As it turns out, they all share the same father, Azazel.

The plot... loses the plot at the point where Azazel reveals that he is actually Satan and has fathered an army of teleporting kids to free him from 'hell' so that he can conquer the world. Azazel is apparently a demonic mutant that was banished in biblical times. So I guess technically this makes Nightcrawler the son of Satan.

While this is all happening the ongoing love triangle between Polaris, Havok and nurse Annie continues... zzzzzzz... Polaris continues down the path of insanity, and the story surrounding the father of Annie's son appears to have been dropped altogether.

The only storyline featured in the collection involves the Juggernaut traveling to Canada to visit Sammy the Fish Boy, only to find Sammy being abused by his father. Juggernaut intervenes. Stuff happens.

Overall, The Draco started out promisingly enough before quickly stinking up the place. Fortunately for me I picked it up in a nick and dent sale for next to nothing. In summary, another Chuck Austen Uncanny Special. 3.5 out of 10.

Uncanny X-Men Volume 4: The Draco TPB, Chuck Austen, Good Book

US $49.58

21h 57m

Marvel Uncanny X-Men Volume 4 The Draco TPB SC Rare New

US $59.00

17d 5h 17m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 4: The Draco TPB, Chuck Austen, Good Book

US $48.29

23d 1h 4m

District X Vol. 1: Mr. M

The Comicologist — Mon, 12 Jan 2009 03:20:55 +0000

District X Vol. 1: Mr. M collects the first six issues of the short lived District X series, originally published some time in 2004. District X is a region within New York, populated largely by mutants. These aren't the 'cool' type of mutants though. No one pops claws or teleports. These are the kind of mutants that smell bad when stressed. The main premise behind the District X series seems to be that even though the District may be 'different', its population is still bound by the law.

Enter the X-Man Bishop. In the ye olde days Bishop was just a gun totting mutant soldier from the future. In District X he's much more the mutant detective. It gives his character a lot more depth, and it has to be said, purpose. In District X, Bishop is partnered with NYPD patrolman Ismael Ortega, to assist in managing the increased crime rate in District X, also known as Mutant Town.

Bishop and Ortega begin investigating a series of crimes that finds them smack bang in the middle of a gang war between two rival mutant crime lords, fighting for control of Mutant Town as well as sale of "Toad Juice" a drug synthesised from the bodily excretion of a mutant boy, known as Toad Boy.

Violence erupts between rival crime lords “Shaky” Kaufman and “Filthy Frankie” Zapruder over a mutant, Toad Boy, and the addictive narcotic he produces (known as “Toad Juice”). When Kaufman learns of the lucrative sales of “Toad Juice” in District X, he raids Zapruder’s facilities and kidnaps the Toad Boy for himself. However, it is unknown that Toad Juice can be fatal to normal humans.

The first six issues also cover the emergence of the mysterious "Mr M", Absolom Zebardyn Mercator, who later pops up to play a pivotal role in the House of M followup, X-Men: The 198. With Mr M becoming increasingly detached from society, he decides that the only way to help District X is by destroying it. Bishop and Ortega are then in a race to not only quell the gang violence, but to stop the destruction of the community they have sworn to protect.

District X Vol. 1: Mr. M is a little like an X-Men version of CSI or Law and Order. To be fair, I don't know whether District X is that good, or whether my whole rating system has been thrown out by Chuck Austen's run on Uncanny X-Men that I'm still labouring through.

While not exactly revolutionary, District X Vol. 1: Mr. M was an enjoyable read, and did enough to make me want to track down Volume 2. Overall I'd give it 6.5 out of 10

New Marvel District X Vol. 1: Mr. M (X-Men)

US $4.09

32m

District X Vol 1: Mr. M Softcover

US $13.99

20h 45m

District X Vol 1 Mr M TP

US $9.74

1d 15h 15m

District X Volume 1 Mr M GN David Hine NM #1-6 X-Men Bishop

US $10.99

1d 17h 49m

District X Vol. 1: Mr. M TPB - Marvel

US $14.99

4d 5h 59m

DISTRICT X VOL. 1 : MR. X TPB Marvel NM/M Bishop

0 Bid

US $2.99

5d 6m

District X: Mr. M Vol. 1 graphic novel with Bishop 2005

US $8.95

6d 23h 18m

X-Men comics DISTRICT X vol. 1 TPB NM (Collects #1-6)

US $5.99

7d 2h 33m

DISTRICT X VOL. 1 & 2 Trade Paperbacks

US $12.00

9d 12h 10m

DISTRICT X: MR M Vol. 1 Marvel TPB Hine Medina Yardin

US $6.95

10d 3h 47m

East Vineland Vol FD District 2 Attack #1 Fire Truck 4x6 Photo Picture Apparatus

US $3.00

11d 1h 33m

DISTRICT X Vol 1 TPB Mr. M by David Hine MARVEL

US $9.99

11d 23h 37m

DISTRICT X TPB VOL 1 MR M DAVID HINE MEDINA PERKINS JUL

US $6.00

12d 18h 34m

Marvel Knights - District X vol 1 by David Hine - TPB MARVEL Softcover NEW

US $10.00

14d 5h 33m

Marvel District X: Mr. M Vol.1 Trade Paperback SC

US $14.99

14d 19h 58m

DISTRICT X VOL 2 TP 1ST PRINT

US $9.99

17d 3h 46m

DISTRICT X Volume 1 Graphic Novel MR. M

US $4.88

20d 1h 58m

District X Vol. 1: Mr. M (X-Men) by David Hine, David Y

US $9.50

22d 22h 59m

DISTRICT X Vol 1 MR M TPB NM Comic X-MEN 2005

US $1.50

26d 17h 53m

Marvel Knights District X districtx comics vol.1 # 6 NM

US $1.89

28d 1h 30m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 3: Holy War

The Comicologist — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 05:18:09 +0000

Like a sadist I picked up Uncanny X-Men Volume 3: Holy War TPB. I really should have learnt my lesson after reading Volumes 1 and 2, but clearly I'm a slow learner. The trade paper back Holy War, collects Uncanny X-Men issues #421-427. In this collection, writer Chuck Austen seems to have struck a new low in his Uncanny X-Men run.

Once again he persists with the angst ridden love triangle of Alex Summers (Havok), Lorna Dane (Polaris) and "Nurse" Annie, which culminates in a wedding and a 'surprise' (that is sarcasm) twist. Does Alex love Lorna? Or does he love Annie? Woe is he. I would write more about it, but that about sums up that plot line.

The other major plot featured in the collection is the "Holy War" itself. This story focuses on The Church of Humanity's attempts to use Nightcrawler to bring down the Catholic Church. Essentially Nightcrawler begins to show signs his faith is wavering. The Church of Humanity, led by a former nun who was raped by a priest (hence her anti-Catholic motivation), target Nightcrawler with plans on making him the next pope and then revealing him to be the devil (due to his appearance)... or something... Basically this plot line, like the rest of the book sucked, and made very little sense. I get the impression that Chuck Austen is not the biggest fan of the Catholic Church.

The only glimmer redeeming feature in this collection is the story of Cain Marko (The Juggernaut) and his relationship with young mutant recruit Sammy. Following the Juggernaut has he tries to redeem himself is the most interesting idea Austen seems to have developed in the three volumes of his run I've read so far.

In summary, this is the worst collection I've read to date, even worse than volume 2. The characterisation of Nightcrawler in particular was hard to take... apparently Austen writes Nightcrawler as an emo kid? On a side note, this is another trade paper back that has Wolverine on the cover even though he appears in the six issues collected briefly. Avoid this one like the plague, unless you just have to have the whole set. 1 out of 10

The Uncanny X-Men Volume 3 Marvel Masterworks Hardcover book SEALED Wolverine!

US $24.95

4d 21h 1m

The Uncanny X-Men Volume 3 Marvel Masterworks Hardcover SEALED Wolverine!

US $24.95

4d 21h 3m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 3 #1 RARE News Stand UPC First Print NM!

0 Bid

US $9.99

6d 2h 29m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 3: Holy War TPB by Chuck Austen

US $12.50

6d 21h 16m

The Uncanny X-Men, Volume 3 NEW by Chris Claremont

US $21.86

7d 15h 23m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 3: Holy War TPB, Chuck Austen, Acc

US $10.79

11d 17h 50m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 3 On Ice GN Chris Claremont Davis

US $11.99

15d 16h 41m

VOLUME 3 Essential X-Men: Uncanny X-Men #145-161 and X-Men Annua...

US $10.00

19d 21h 35m

Marvel Comics- UNCANNY X-MEN THE NEW AGE (ON ICE) VOLUME 3 tpb

US $7.95

21d 21h 44m

Uncanny X-Men-The New Age Volume 3: On Ice Softcover

US $13.99

22d 22h 43m

The Uncanny X-Men, Volume 3, Claremont, Chris and Byr 9780785145707 NEW Book

US $20.50

27d 13h 38m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 2: Dominant Species

The Comicologist — Fri, 12 Dec 2008 05:01:13 +0000

I read Uncanny X-Men Volume 2: Dominant Species TPB straight after I finished the mediocre Volume 1: Hope. Let me start by saying that Chuck Austen's first arc, Hope, wasn't the worst thing I've read, but it was by far not the best either. It wasn't until I finished Volume 2: Dominant Species that I realized that the bad reputation Chuck Austen seems to have with X-Men fans is entirely well deserved.

Dominant Species is like the three pronged turd. Poor plotting, poor art and poor characterization. The main thread running through Dominant Species is that people with similar character characteristics gravitate toward one another. A majority of the story is told from the point of view of Angel and Husk. There's a bit of old school sexual tension.

There's also a new villain, Max Lobbo, who's head of some sort of mutant werewolf pack. Who he is, where he comes from and what his motivation is, doesn't receive much attention. He works/runs a company that is owned by Warren Worthington (Angel). Besides that Lobbo kills people and mutants for fun, and has a pack of werewolf mutants following him around that seem to do nothing more than repeat everything everyone says.

At one point Wolverine gets pummelled and then has to be rescued by Northstar and taken away to heal. Is this the same Wolverine that survived an explosion and healed himself from skeletal remains in his Civil War tie-in?

So basically, a new bad guy is introduced, but barely fleshed out, and Husk has a thing for Angel, although Angel does not really know that. Havok is brought out of his coma, and Lorna Dane (Polaris) returns.

From what I've read so far Austen applies the same template across his stories. He ticks the 'unrequited love' box, and also makes sure to include a little vague social commentary. Female characters exist solely to stare longingly at their male counter parts.

According to the Amazon description, Dominant Species was illustrated by "superstar" Japanese artist Kia Asamiya. The X-Men clearly take on a manga flavor, but in this instance, I can't say it's a good thing. Some of the characters look just plain weird, and it's often hard to get past the nose. Another thing that stuck out for me was the costume Polaris rocks up in. It looks like she has a set of wings coming out of her head, and I have no idea why.

For me, there were only two interesting elements in this collection. One, the concept of secondary mutation. Mutants mutating further, for example, Angel develops a healing factor and Iceman begins to turn into ice, full time. Two, the idea that Juggernaut is not always such a bad guy. Some people would no doubt hate this aspect, but in a story as pedestrian as the one played out in Dominant Species, people should be grateful for small mercies.

In summary, this is officially the worst trade paper back collection I have read to date. 2 out of 10

UNCANNY X-MEN~MARVEL~DOMINANT SPECIES~VOL. #417-#420 RUN~2003~VG+++

US $16.00

1d 15h 2m

Marvel Comics Uncanny X-MEN Dominant Species Part1 #417

US $12.00

9d 18h 53m

Marvel Uncanny X-MEN Dominant Species Part 2 Issue #418

US $12.00

9d 21h 25m

Uncanny X-Men #419 Dominant Species Part Three!

US $1.87

24d 12h 55m

Uncanny X-Men # 418 vol 1 2003 Dominant Species

US $1.75

27d 23h 43m

Uncanny X-Men Volume 1: Hope

The Comicologist — Mon, 08 Dec 2008 22:51:23 +0000

I picked up the trade paper back Uncanny X-Men Volume 1: Hope TPB (Uncanny X-Men) in a nick and dent sale with relatively low expectations. Why? The book carried Chuck Austen's name on the cover, the guy that has been roundly criticized for steering the title directly in to some of its more disappointing moments.

This trade paper collects Uncanny X-Men issues #410-415, and covers off a couple of story arcs. The first deals with the team sent on a rescue mission only to learn that it is the Juggernaut they have been sent to help. Black Tom Cassidy is smack bang in the middle of a secondary mutation, and Juggernaut needs help. Fairly stock standard stuff. The early issues also deal with Professor X tracking down a young mutant named Sammy who has a fish like appearance. We are also introduced to Annie, a nurse caring for a comatose patient that later turns out to be Havok.

In the final two issues, Northstar joins the undermanned group, at the request of Xavier, to assist them to bring in an explosive mutant child unable to control his powers. The big revelation for me here was that Northstar is gay, and has a crush on Bobby Drake (aka. Iceman), who happens to be going through a secondary mutation of his own.

By the end of the collection, Austen seems to have all his players in the game, and it feels like I've just read six issues of 'set-up'. One of the problems with issues #410-415 seems to be that Austen was operating with the X-Men 'C' grade squad to a certain extent. Angel? I've never been a huge fan. Stacy X? Pheromone powers? I've read Austen quoted as saying he wanted to "inject some soap" into his Uncanny X-Men run, which seems to be the exact result he achieved. Is that a good thing? I'm not so sure. A love triangle between Angel, Stacy X and Husk? I'm not sure that I could have been less interested. The whole unrequited love angle doesn't work for me either. The Annie/Havok and Northstar/Iceman thing just didn't float my boat. I want to read an X-Men story, not a rejected script from the OC.

Nightcrawler and Wolverine both feature in the squad in an obvious attempt at widening the audience, but it's important to remember that while this series was running Grant Morrison was working on The New X-Men and Chris Claremont on X-Treme X-Men so perhaps Austen was largely assigned the "C" squad?

To be blunt, Uncanny X-Men Volume 1: Hope wasn't quite as bad as I'd been led to believe, but in saying that, I would hardly describe it as an unforgettable comic book experience. Overall I'd give this collection 4 out of 10.